I finally did it. It's a bit embarrassing, seeing how I should have graduated officially in 2002.
I had four general education classes left (two world history, one religion, and one chemistry) and one major class left (any 400 level Computer Science). However, during early 2002 when I was supposed to be finishing these classes my company took off and demanded more than full-time from me. School was simply impossible.
A few years have passed since then and my company is out of the early start-up phase. Over the last year I've been able to finish up these final requirements via evening and online courses.
Now I have a Bachelor of Science in Computer Science from Brigham Young University!